Thursday, February 18, 2010

She Can Sue!!

Free speech activists are, apparently, thrilled that Katherine Evans is able to sue for her right to freedom of speech in regards to supposed cyberbullying. Evans is a south Florida high school student who created a Facebook page dedicated to criticizing one of her teachers, Sarah Phelps. The page no longer exists, and had already been taken down two months prior to when Evans received three days suspension and was removed from her Advance Placement classes. Evans, now 19 and a sophomore at the University of Florida, is now suing her former principle with the help of the ACLU. The issues being brought up on the issue are, according the the ACLU the First and section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendments (following respectively):
  • Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
  • Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. 
Considering Evans was suspended in 2007 and the ACLU caught wind of the case in 2008 and it received its O.K. go(!) in 2010, I'd say this is an issue of principle. I don't think this is a landmark case for the ACLU, but it is a very defining moment for proponents for the expungement of cyberbullying. According to STOP Cyberbullying.org, Evans is a cyberbully by creating a website dedicated to slandering another individual; however, it's prudent to note that if you take the 14-17 "are you a cyberbully?" quiz, Evans' singular action gives her a score of 1, which incidentally makes her a cyber-saint (ironic?).
So how do we feel/respond to this case?
I think we have to consider what the website represented: A student vented/ranted/slandered a teacher online. I vent/rant/slander professors fairly often. Ask me about CSUMB's Spanish department, for example, and I'll tell you about my experience. Or, consider that just the other day in class a group of students and I discussed our experiences with one professor that I love and another student absolutely hates. I certainly saw that professor in a different light and a few students who have never had that professor have some...presuppositions, but really it's a matter of opinion. Is it, however, a different situation when I publicly post my rants and attach a name for billions to see? (I'm laughing a little bit.) I'm a college student and, I'm not going to lie, I check rate my professors.combefore I sign up for a class and I rate my professors when I'm done with a class. I haven't, prior to reading about Evans' case, considered the possibility that this might be cyberbullying. From my perspective, ratemyprofs offers critical need-to-know information; the professors who receive bad ratings probably see the site as offensive from their perspective. Whose perspective needs to be protected?

~
Okay, so, quick driving update:
I didn't driving to church after all. So don't think, "see it wasn't so bad," cause it never happened. So it probably is THAT bad.
Driving, really though, isn't terrible. I like driving stick more than auto. I feel like with manual I'm more in control of the car than I am in an automatic. Go figure.
On Sunday my friend had me drive to Target again. I was trying to pump myself up..."I'm not going to panic. I wont even ask Kelly what to do. I'm going to be fine" Got into the car, "See, everything is fine. I'm going to put on the clutch..turn the car on..take off the parking brake, which isn't an e-brake...shift to reverse...apply some gas..slowly take off the clutch...KELLY GET OFF YOUR PHONE AND PAY ATTENTION, THE CAR IS MOVING"
We're going to try spending some time in the car reading a book or something to see if I can get used to being behind the wheel. We'll see how that goes...

No comments:

Post a Comment