HCOM 437
May 16th, 2010
Fletcher
Mini-Production Text Final: Criticism of Class and Religion in Twelfth Night
Twelfth Night is assumed to have been written towards the beginning of the seventeenth century, specifically 1601. This particular date is important to how the play is consumed because it creates a historical context in which power in religion and class was becoming increasingly challenged in England as Elizabeth I’s reign was coming to an end (Doran 109 - 110). Twelfth Night mirrors this struggle between religion and class through the theme of the follies of ambition within the realm of religious and class-filled societies. The theme is exemplified in the development of the character Malvolio as he attempts to elevate in society and ultimately complicates his puritan-like ideals.
The presence of religion wasn’t being challenged so much as the role of religious power on English society was, especially as the presence of Puritanism began to increase in England (although Puritanism did not reach its height until the late seventeenth century) (Cody). The Church of England under Queen Elizabeth I defined providence as more reliant upon God to work in men and women and create for them their destinies (eg.Queen Elizabeth I believed firmly in her divine appointment as Queen of England) Man, accordingly should reflect his birth right and fall into the proper order of things (Great Chain of Being). A debate at the time within the Church, however, represented a contrasting Anglican1 viewpoint in which man has more control over his destiny and deity is less defined by time and nature of being and more so by man’s willingness to do “good” works, with that of a puritan viewpoint in which the Bible was the center of a man’s life and thus his lifestyle should represent an extreme rigidity based on the Bible’s contents. The Anglican viewpoint represented a more extreme version of the “nonconformist” ideal that religion was present in society, but society didn’t need a legalistic take on it that was traditional to the Church of England (Hunt 227 - 229). This conflict within the Church is dramatized in Twelfth Night by the character of Malvolio, as he is described as “a kind of puritan” but throughout the play approximates this labeling in his ambitious plight.
It is pertinent to note that Malvolio’s character doesn’t represent the personification of the Church nor Shakespeare’s opinion on religion, but rather the ideas concerning how individuals should respond to divine appointment and/or free will - if either exist. Consequently, Malvolio represents a puritan individual: one who accepts the theology thereof, and conducts his life according to a rules-based approach. His challenge, therefore, becomes one of elevating outside of his earthly appointment; rising out of his lower status through the sacrament of marriage, all the while doing so with an inflated ego.
Malvolio, therefore, is also not a personification of puritans. He is like a puritan in his manner, disposition and conduct, but he does not don a traditional black robe. If Shakespeare had intended for Malvolio to be a puritan, it’s safe to say he would have stereotyped the character more. It’s important to keep this lack of a stereotype surrounding Malvolio’s character in mind because it has an impact on the meaning of the play as it concerns Malvolio. A priestly status to Malvolio’s puritan complex would make him more authoritative and relatable. As it is, he is everyman: he has a fault (he’s a puritan) and he has an ambition (to rise in status). With this in mind, the audience is more capable to visualize Malvolio with less mocking and on a lower platform.
Malvolio’s character is described by Maria as, “a kind of puritan” (2.3.140) and as “sick of self-love” (1.5.90) by Olivia. This tells the reader two things about Malvolio: that he is, as aforementioned, an example of a puritan, and his motivations come from a source other than God - himself. As he stands, he is a steward to Olivia detached from enjoying the lavish lifestyle of the upper-class he dreams of living. Before the provocation of Sir Toby’s plot against Malvolio, he is found daydreaming about marrying Olivia and becoming a count, “There is example for’t; the lady of the Strachy married to the yeoman of the wardrode,” (2.5.39-40). Malvolio’s desire to have more of an impact on his life draws from his lack of ability to criticize those who criticize him. His toughest adversaries, Sirs Toby and Andrew, drunkards though they may be, are more respected and of more worth socially than Malvolio. Indeed, Malvolio’s only criticism of any other character before he believes Olivia is in love with him is of the fool who is arguably lower socially than Malvolio. In Malvolio’s mind, a hint of affection from Olivia is enough to elevate him above those he wishes to see fall. Love, then, becomes a convenient emotion for Malvolio to take advantage of.
Whether Malvolio loves Olivia affectionately is questionable. In his conversation with himself - before he finds the letter - Malvolio creates examples of Olivia’s affection,
“Besides, she uses me
with a more exalted respect than any one else that
follows her. What should I think on’t?” (2.5.26-28),
with a more exalted respect than any one else that
follows her. What should I think on’t?” (2.5.26-28),
But aligns the joy of the possible marriage with his desires,
“And then to have the humour of state;
and after a demure travel of regard, telling them I know
my place as I would they should do theirs, to ask
for my kinsman Toby-” (2.5.52-55).
Malvolio’s love is centered on his love for elevated society, to which he eventually falls to its derision, and not for Olivia. Malvolioand after a demure travel of regard, telling them I know
my place as I would they should do theirs, to ask
for my kinsman Toby-” (2.5.52-55).
When Malvolio becomes the main target of Sir Toby’s schemes, the allowances in aristocracy change. Before the plot, Malvolio was an annoyance to the characters - the snob within the household that ended a few late-night parties; however, as Malvolio begins to envision himself as an equal to Olivia and greater than Sirs Toby and Andrew, he gets more bold in his rebukes and becomes a problem. Malvolio’s desire to rise in power is no longer a game (although it is played out as one) and needs to be corrected.
Malvolio’s punishment for his ambitious desires is both a correction and a game. It’s a game in the sense that Toby, Maria and Fabian are having fun while they receive retribution for Malvolio’s reprimand. They are able to easily convince Olivia that Malvolio is mad and for this receive a license to lock him away in a dark room. By locking Malvolio away into a dark room, Shakespeare is mirroring the treatment of insane individuals in England at the time and refers to the theory that puritanism was a psychological disorder (“A History of Mental Hospitals”) (Hunt 290). This is interesting because Malvolio’s ambitions are consequently
aligned with insanity, and, moreover, his symbol as somewhat of a puritan is likewise aligned.
There is a right and a wrong way to elevate status as represented in Twelfth Night. Malvolio, much to his chagrin, navigates the wrong path and meets hurtle upon hurtle until he is thwarted. His seclusion in a dark room, taunted by his superiors, shows the audience that elevation is destructive, especially if procured incorrectly. Malvolio is left his own folly that is fundamentally destructive, whereas the folly of the social structure is proven victorious again. Look, for example, at Maria’s elevation. She put up with Sir Toby’s game and played into his folly. As a result he marries her. Maria was not in charge of her destiny, but was allowed to advance at the call of Sir Toby. Malvolio’s problem, then, and the problem of any individual who fails to change his or her status, is that they may be relying on chance, or his or her own supposed prerogative to “change one’s stars” as the idiom goes. Similarly, Twelfth Night depicts correct dogma for change.
Throughout Twelfth Night a play on the contrasting religious elements is present. Malvolio, as strenuously aforementioned, represents a very rigid protestant puritan. The rest of the characters represent traditional, nonconformist, Church of England congregants, to varying degrees. Part of Malvolio’s punishment along with being corrected about his ambitions is to be corrected religiously, which is what Feste serves to do as Sir Topas, “What is the opinion of Pythagoras concerning wild fowl?” (4.2.50-51). Pythagoras was a Greek philosopher who believed “that a soul can transmigrate from one creature to another,” clearly a very pagan ideology (Weller). Malvolio responds to this ideology in a christian manner, “I think nobly of the soul, and no way approve his opinion” (4.2.55). Regardless of how correct Malvolio’s response may have been, Sir Topas (Feste) finds a way to make it sound orthodox and more puritan, “Thou shalt hold the opinion of Pythagoras ere I will allow of thy wits, and fear to kill a woodcock, lest thou dispossess the soul of thy grandam” (4.2.58-60) (Hunt 290), and even goes as far as identifying a demon possessing Malvolio, “Adieu, goodman devil” (4.2.131).
Shakespeare, here, is correctly identifying the annoyance of legalism in religion and the annoyance of individuals who employ such a legalism in their lifestyles. If the character of Malvolio is accepted as the ultimate example of a failed attempt at status change and thus provides the most profound reasons why (and I believe he is) this nuisance is a huge driving factor in status. Elizabethans accepted that God had the greatest influence on who was born and to what he or she was going to be worth, (again, divine appointment); yet, there was very little about how to conduct a lifestyle according to this divinity. Do individuals just accept a lavish lifestyle and live lavishly, or do they have a responsibility to their livelihood? Malvolio thought the former, “I frown the while; and perchance wind up watch, or play with my—some rich jewel” (2.5.59-60), and such frivolousness was his demise. Sir Toby, who for the majority of the play embodied the frivolousness Malvolio dreamed of, conclusively recognizes the greater responsibility of his position, “If he may be conveniently delivered, I would he were, for I am now so far in offence with my niece that I cannot pursue with any safety this sport to the upshot” (4.2.68-71). Subsequently, divine appointment reflects an individual’s ability to uphold the standards of his or her status.
Malvolio isn’t successful in elevating his status. At the conclusion of the play his call to revenge, “I'll be revenged on the whole pack of you” (5.1.378), is taken lightheartedly and
offhandedly as the rest of the characters focus on matrimony. Malvolio’s conclusion in the
play is confusing as contemporarily it would be prime to have him be elevated or find a less materialistic and superficial aim in his life; we like redemption for the underdog. Shakespeare, however, gives Malvolio the most unhappy ending for a character in any of his comedies: Malvolio was the subject of derision and had no redemption nor any redemptive qualities; he very well could have ended with less of a status within the household than he began with. To this extent, Shakespeare is telling the audience that Malvolio isn’t an underdog and he isn’t to be pitied nor redeemed. Changing status has a process and one will fall to its folly before her or she will elevate, if that person will elevate at all. Within the same sphere, man also doesn’t have control over the livelihood to which he is appointed by God.
Twelfth Night in all of its comedic content makes a larger statement about the worth of man and his plight towards happiness. In the audience, we can see the detriment of this plight as Malvolio falls to the jeers of those stationed above him. Similarly, we can also see that we can only be successful in elevating if we are willing to go along with the lunacy of those stationed above us and are equally willing to walk in the faith of our lack of sovereignty over our lives.
Works Cited
"A History of Mental Hospitals." MedHunters - Nursing and Healthcare Jobs. Web. 15 May 2010.
Cody, David, and George Landow. "Puritanism in England." The Victorian Web: An Overview. 29 Dec. 2009. Web. 15 May 2010.
Doran, Susan. Queen Elizabeth I. New York : New York University Press, 2003. 109 - 110. Print.
Hunt, Maurice. "Malvolio, Viola, and the Question of Instrumentality: Defining Providence in "Twelfth Night"." Studies in Philology 90.3 (Summer, 1993): 227 - 297. Web. 13 May 2010.
Weller, Phillip. "Shakespeare Navigator: Twelfth Night." Shakespeare Navigators. N.p., 2008. Web. 13 May 2010.
